Chapter 11 of the text Using Technology with Classroom Instruction That Works discusses how to enhance student’s critical thinking and problem solving skills through generating and testing hypotheses. While traditionally this type of investigation has been used primarily in science classes, the authors of this text clearly demonstrate that this form of instruction can be used across content. Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, and Malenoski state that there are six activities that teachers can incorporate into their instruction that will enhance students abilities to research and solve problems:
1. Systems Analysis – Students engage in analyzing a system in order to make predictions about how it would change if parts of it were altered or removed.
2. Problem Solving – Students look at potential solutions to a problem
3. Historical Investigation – Students analyze a historical event to make educated guesses about the events that transpired
4. Invention – Students create something to fulfill a pre-determined need
5. Experimental Inquiry – Students make observations, generate a hypothesis, then design an experiment to test their hypothesis
6. Decision Making – Students are actively involved in looking at various solutions to a problem in order to come up with the most logical decision
(Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, Malenoski, 2007)
Each one of these activities all employ elements of the constructionist theory
in that they encourage students to be actively engaged and construct an artifact/product to demonstrate their understanding. I have found that when I have used this type of constructionist approach in my classroom, motivation and engagement skyrockets and I am often surprised at the creativity and quality of work that is produced by my students.
For the last three years I have had my students participate in The Great Water Challenge. Within this unit students learn about the global water crisis, water quality, and local history. At the beginning of the unit students research water quality and identify how humans and the development of cities have impacted water quality over time. During their research students also identify the three largest point and non-point source polluters in our state and analyze current actions being taken to help limit this pollution. While students are researching water pollution, they are also learning about the settlement and development of our own watershed. Students then build a 3-model of our local watershed and make predictions about water quality based on when/where humans have settled and how industries have historically utilized our watershed. Students use their 3-d models to identify potential problems, and then we bring in various community members and non-profit organizations to speak with us about the realities of our of the water quality in our local water sources.
When students have gathered their information and have a good understanding how/why water pollution is a problem, they are then responsible for creating a public service announcement to educate our local community about how people in our community can limit and/or prevent water pollution. I find this activity to be highly engaging for students and many of them were very proud when their public service announcement was shared on our cities’ website. Each year I have done this project, I have made multiple changes to improve student productively and quality of research. I have found that technology has been a great motivator for many students and has allowed us to analyze and synthesize information from various resources. This type of constructionist project takes a lot of time, but I believe that the providing students with the opportunity to engage in an authentic learning experience is definitely worth the time.
I have also had students create a variety of movies in my classroom. The main tool I have used is a free program found at www.animoto.com. There is a free version that allows users to create 30 second videos and there is a free educator upgrade that allows teachers and 50 of their students to created videos of unlimited length. I have used this program to provide students with a medium in which they can using text, images and audio to demonstrate their knowledge of a particular concept we learning in the classroom. I was excited to see the simulation software links at the end of Chapter 11 in the text Using Technology with Classroom Instruction That Works, and look forward to exploring these site to see how I can incorporate them into my classroom. (Pitler et al., 2007)
I believe that elements of the constructionist theory have strong implications for the classroom, and can produce a quality learning experience for students. Dr. Orey states that “people learn best when they build an external artifact or something they can share with others.” (Laureate Education, Inc., 2011). While I think many educators shy away from this type of activity due to pressures of mandated tests and lack of time, research has shown that many students who have participated in these lessons/activities performed at standard or above standard compared to students taught in a traditional format. “Those students using simulation software not only recorded higher test scores but also – and perhaps more important – showed overwhelming enthusiasm while learning the material.” (Pitler et al., 2007, pg 214).
References:
Laureate Education, Inc. (Producer). (2011). Program seven: Constructionist and constructivist learning theories [Video webcast]. Bridging learning theory, instruction and technology. Retrieved from http://laureate.ecollege.com/ec/crs/default.learn?CourseID=5700267&CPURL=laureate.ecollege.com&Survey=1&47=2594577&ClientNodeID=984650&coursenav=0&bhcp=1
Pitler, H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski, K. (2007). Using technology with classroom instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.
I went and checked out the Animoto website and I think it might work for our Virtual Enterprise commercial. How do you go about getting an educator upgrade and does it include music that you can add? We also need to be able to burn this into a DVD so we can submit it for competition. Thanks so much for sharing this site!
ReplyDeleteFred
Fred,
ReplyDeleteI am glad you got a chance to check out this site . . . it is a great tool for the classroom! To get a free educator upgrade log into the site and click on My account in the upper right corner. When that page loads click on Account overview and scroll to the bottom to find animoto for educators. Enrolling in this give you and 50 students unlimited videos for 180 days. There is also an option to create a DVD, but I think you have to pay for it. Have fun with this!! Oh yeah . . . and there is music included with the program or you can upload your own music. I have had students create their own sound tracks in garageband. If your school is a PC school there is also a free program you can download from the Microsoft website called photostory. Before my school went exclusively MAC, I used this with me students as well . . . great program and easy to use. You can also check out www.photopeach.com for a similar program. The transitions don't look quite as fancy as animoto, but you have more control over the music. Let me know what you decide to use. I would love to see your final commercials.
Katie
Hi Katie,
ReplyDeleteI have so much to say! First, I found it interesting that no matter how it was broken up and which theorists discuss the principles of constructionism, the means all went back to the same end! While you mentioned some of the principles in the textbook, I also compared those same principles to Orey's theories of constructionism which were:
-Extracting essential concepts and skills from examples and experiences
-Engaging learners in learning
-Encouraging question posing
-Confronting conceptions and misconceptions (Orey, 2001)
Essentially, the same theory of formulating a hypothesis and using active leaning to get students to find their own results! Oh so very Socratic in theory!
Also, I LOVE your assignment! It seems as though it really engages the students, while at the same time truly teaching that about the water pollution issue and helping the community. Bravo to you!
In terms of http://animoto.com/, I can only say, thank you!! What perfect timing! I actually just gave my students an assignment where they would create a travel video and was trying to give them some suggestions as to which programs to use—this looks simply perfect!
As always, I enjoyed your post! Jenn
Orey, M. (Ed.). (2001). Emerging perspectives on learning, teaching, and technology. Retrieved from http://projects.coe.uga.edu/epltt/index.php?title=Main_Page
Pitler H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski, K. (2007). Using technology with classroom instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.
Hi Katie!
ReplyDeleteI was glad to read your blog this week, especially when I read about your projects involving fresh water. While many think our next great world crisis may be about oil, there is an increasing number of people who believe the crisis will be about fresh water. We in this country take for granted the availability of drinking water, but for so many around the world, it has become a luxury, more precious than minerals or oil. Getting yor students to use technology in the constructionism theory of learning by creating public service announcements is a great idea.
I am in total agreement with your last point about students building external artifacts. I think Orey really tries to overcomplicate this, because I think we as teachers all know a student takes greater pride in a project when they know it will be presented. How many times have we heard the question of "will this be graded?" when the students are working? One of the techniques I use a lot is having my students present their "artifacts" to the class, whether it be a project, or a PowerPoint presentation, or simply how they found an answer. When the students know their work is going to be displayed, they make a better effort, which goes to greater knowledge.
I am planning on using Windows Movie Maker this year to build on a project the students did last year, which was a biography of a famous mathematician. They wrote the biography last year, so I hope to have them narrate their own story while the pictures and diagrams play.
Thanks again for a great blog post!
Todd Deschaine
Todd,
ReplyDeleteI agree with you in that Orey does seem to over complicate things that teachers often know. I know that his background is different in terms of being a researcher of educational theory . . . but I still get a little bogged down in all the theory behind what teachers should and should not be doing in the classroom.
I have also found that when students know their work is going to be viewed by others their motivation and effort seems to increase. While intrinsic motivation is the ideal that educators strive for, we know that if an assignment is not graded or does not count for anything that it probably won't be completed. I wish all my students loved learning just for the sake of expanding their horizons and knowledge base, but it seems my middle school students often have other priorities. : )
I haven't used windows movie maker (we are a MAC school) but I have used photostory. Photostory is a free movie making program that can be downloaded from the microsoft website. I loved using this program because it gives you a great product and it is easy to use. My 6 year old made a great movie the other day : ) If you have a chance check it out.
Hi, Byron from your Walden class
ReplyDeleteI see you talked about the state that there are six activities that teachers can incorporate into their instruction that will enhance students abilities to research and solve problems. Here are two other activities that I feel will enhance students abilities
Scaffolded Instruction
Scaffolded instruction is a concept that has grown out of research on how individuals learn. This concept is based on the idea that at the beginning of learning, students need a great deal of support gradually, this support is taken away to allow students to try their independence. This is what is called the gradual release of responsibility. If students are unable to achieve independence, the teacher brings back the support system to help students experience success until they are able to achieve independence.
Prior knowledge activation
Activating prior knowledge is another instructional strategy that is important in research-based instruction . Many different strategies can be used in activating prior knowledge and most of these strategies help students become independent in activating their own prior knowledge. Research on schema theory and prior knowledge has clearly shown that students construct meaning by using their prior knowledge to interact with the text. A thematic organization in which themes are carefully developed with related pieces of literature also supports the activation and development of prior knowledge by reading several related selections, students build on their prior knowledge from previous selections as they read the next selection.